"I'm not comfortable eating a watch battery." That's how researcher Christopher Bettinger describes one of the biggest obstacles for sending tiny medical robots into the human body for diagnosing and treating diseases.
These devices run on batteries like those in watches, and they usually are made of toxic materials such as lithium.
This month, Bettinger, based at Carnegie Mellon University, presented his group's work on creating edible, non-toxic batteries at a national meeting of the American Chemical Society, the world's largest scientific society.
The Bettinger group's battery is made of melanin, a dark pigment found in human skin, hair, eyes and the brain. Bettinger says the current prototype lasts "for about 16 hours" and then "degrades to benign components."
"I have eaten one of my batteries and I'm still fine — I'd be fine eating my battery every single day of my life!" he says.
The battery is made from cuttlefish ink extracts and could be used to power "pacemakers, neurostimulators, devices to deliver drugs at a specific time, ingestible cameras, and glucose monitors," Bettinger says.
Researchers have experimented with melanin-based electronics since the 1970s, some even winning the Nobel Prize for it. Nevertheless, the discoveries had remained largely forgotten until the late 2000's, when a type of melanin was shown to be an electronic conductor which sparked the renewed interest.
Riding this tide, Bettinger tried his hand at creating semiconductor chips with melanin. "It didn't really work at all, but it turns out that the same property that makes it a terrible transistor makes it a great ingredient for a battery," he says.
By 2013, Bettinger had his first prototype of a melanin-based battery, with a lifetime of five hours. Three years of subsequent research tripled the battery life and resulted in "preliminary [partnership] discussions with a few people — mainly big pharma," he says.
Making batteries with melanin "is a very, very interesting and powerful idea," says Phillip Messersmith, a professor of material sciences at the University of California, Berkeley. "Biological inspirations are really powerful in the context of sustainable energy storage and sustainable materials."
Gregory Payne, a professor of bioengineering at the University of Maryland, says "it's pretty important research."
Bettinger says the melanin battery research is "still in the preliminary stage." While the team "anticipates very little toxicity response" to the melanin battery, he says, no clinical trials have been carried out to prove its safety.
The current battery prototype contains a small amount of Teflon, which "is expensive and toxic in nature ... dangerous to humans and the environment," says Clara Santato, a professor of engineering physics at École Polytechnique de Montréal. According to Santato, research to create a Teflon-free melanin battery is underway.
Even then, safety questions linger. "I don't know that there is consensus on the toxicity of melanin," Messersmith says. "It's an open question ... [although] I do not foresee significant problems in the GI tract applications."
Melanin comes in many different forms, and some aren't as good for the purpose of making edible batteries.
"One of the concerns about melanin in the brain is that it doesn't degrade rapidly," Payne says. "What is mystifying to me is that melanin is a relatively abundant material in your body but there's very little understanding of what function it performs. [Chemists] are still debating it. ... It's not that easy to figure out the structure."
Scientists say there's no guarantee that the lab results can be replicated for mass production since so little is known about melanin.
"It can, for sure, be improved," Santato says. "It's really now the engineering of the molecules."